Disclosure: Reviewers’ Guild may earn a commission from some links on this site. It never affects what we recommend.
Quick answer: A budget pet food can be perfectly good if its label says it is “complete and balanced” for your pet’s life stage. To find real value, compare foods by cost per calorie (or per day of feeding), not by bag price, since cheaper foods often have fewer calories per cup. Feeding the right amount for your pet’s ideal weight saves money too.
How we put this guide together: We are not vets and we didn’t run feeding trials. This guide explains how to judge value using the label rules set by the Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO). We don’t rank budget brands. Prices change constantly and differ by store, and the method below lets you compare any foods yourself in a few minutes.
Budget pet food: what matters and what doesn’t
| Check | Why it matters | Where to find it |
|---|---|---|
| “Complete and balanced” for your pet’s life stage | The food meets nutritional standards on its own | The nutritional adequacy statement on the bag |
| Calories per cup or can | Lets you work out how much you’ll actually feed | The “Calorie Content” statement |
| Cost per day of feeding | The real price, not the bag price | Your own quick calculation (below) |
| Marketing words (“premium”, “holistic”, “natural”) | Tell you little about nutrition | Front of the bag; give them less weight |
Step 1: check it’s complete and balanced
AAFCO explains that “complete” means the food contains all the nutrients required, and “balanced” means they’re present in the correct ratios. The statement also names a life stage: growth, adult maintenance, gestation/lactation or all life stages. As AAFCO puts it, “different quantities and ratios of nutrients are necessary for different life stages”, so match the food to your pet.
Avoid relying on any food labelled “intended for intermittent or supplementary feeding only” as your pet’s main diet. AAFCO says that wording appears on products that don’t meet the standards for complete and balanced nutrition.
Step 2: compare cost per day, not price per bag
Every complete pet food must show a calorie content statement, in kilocalories per kilogram and per familiar unit such as a cup or can. That’s the key to comparing value. A cheaper bag with fewer calories per cup can cost as much per day as a pricier one, because you have to feed more of it.
To compare two foods:
- Note the kcal per cup (or per can) and the number of cups in the bag (or the bag weight and kcal per kg).
- Work out the total calories in the bag, then divide the bag price by that number to get the cost per 1,000 kcal.
- Multiply by the calories your pet needs each day (your vet can tell you, or use the feeding directions as a starting point) to get the cost per day.
Do this for two or three foods and the real bargain usually becomes obvious.
Step 3: feed the right amount
Overfeeding wastes money as well as being bad for your pet. AAFCO notes that feeding directions “are guidelines that may need modification to meet a particular pet’s needs”. Feed for your pet’s ideal weight, weigh or measure each portion, and adjust with your vet if your pet is gaining or losing weight.
More ways to save on pet food
- Buy larger bags if you can store them sealed, cool and dry, and use them before the best-by date. The price per kilogram is usually lower.
- Consider store brands. If the label says complete and balanced for your pet’s life stage, a store brand can be a sound choice.
- Use subscriptions or loyalty discounts for food your pet already eats well. Compare the discounted cost per day, not just the percentage off.
- Mix wet and dry thoughtfully. Wet food costs more per calorie but adds moisture. Some owners feed mostly dry with some wet, counting both towards the daily calories. See our wet vs dry cat food guide.
- Switch gradually over several days when changing foods, to avoid an upset stomach, which can mean an expensive vet visit.
Is budget pet food good enough?
Our verdict: For most healthy pets, yes, provided the label says complete and balanced for their life stage and they do well on it (good energy, healthy weight, normal stools, healthy coat). Choose on cost per day of feeding, not on bag price or marketing words.
Talk to your vet before switching if your pet has a medical condition, food allergies or a prescribed diet. In those cases the right food matters more than the price.
Frequently asked questions
Is cheap dog or cat food bad?
Not necessarily. A low-cost food that’s labelled complete and balanced for your pet’s life stage meets the nutritional standards it’s labelled for. Judge by the label, your pet’s health and the cost per day of feeding, not by price alone.
How do I compare the real cost of two pet foods?
Use the calorie content statement on each bag to work out the cost per 1,000 kcal, then multiply by your pet’s daily calorie needs. That gives the cost per day, which is a fairer comparison than bag price.
What does “complete and balanced” mean on pet food?
According to AAFCO, complete means the food contains all the nutrients required, and balanced means they’re in the correct ratios, for the life stage named on the label.
Are store-brand pet foods any good?
They can be. Check for a complete and balanced statement for your pet’s life stage and compare the cost per day. If your pet does well on it, a store brand can be a sensible way to save.
Further reading
- Wet vs Dry Cat Food: Which Is Better for Your Cat?
- Hill’s Science Diet vs Royal Canin
- Pet Health Products Worth Buying
Sources
- AAFCO, “Reading Labels” (Understanding Pet Food). aafco.org
Get more Pet Health & Nutrition guides — free
New expert articles delivered straight to your inbox. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.